Refrigerant Types Explained: R-290 vs R-134a vs R-404A
The refrigerant inside your commercial refrigerator affects its energy efficiency, its environmental footprint, and increasingly, whether you can legally install it. This guide covers the three most common refrigerants in commercial refrigeration and what the transition to low-GWP alternatives means for equipment buyers.
What is GWP and why it matters
Global Warming Potential (GWP) measures how much heat a greenhouse gas traps relative to CO₂ over 100 years. CO₂ itself has a GWP of 1. Refrigerants range from GWP 3 (R-290, propane) to GWP 3,922 (R-404A). High-GWP refrigerants are being phased down worldwide under the Kigali Amendment and, in the United States, under the EPA's AIM Act.
For equipment buyers, this matters because regulations are restricting where and when high-GWP equipment can be installed. Buying a unit with R-404A today may mean buying a unit that cannot be recharged with the same refrigerant in 5–10 years.
The three refrigerants you will see most often
R-290 (propane) — GWP 3
R-290 is a natural hydrocarbon refrigerant with near-zero global warming potential. It is thermodynamically efficient, widely available, and increasingly common in new commercial refrigeration equipment. In our database of commercial refrigerators, 1,624 models (84.5%) use R-290.
The trade-off is flammability. R-290 is an A3 (highly flammable) refrigerant, which limits the charge size in self-contained commercial units to about 150 grams under current standards. This is enough for small and mid-sized reach-in units but not for large systems. Installation does not require special ventilation for charge-limited units, but technicians must be certified for flammable refrigerants.
R-134a — GWP 1,430
R-134a is the incumbent workhorse. It is non-flammable (A1 safety class), well understood by service technicians, and compatible with a wide range of compressor designs. 1 models (0.1%) in our database use R-134a.
Its GWP of 1,430 puts it in the moderate-impact category. It is not yet subject to the same restrictions as R-404A, but the trajectory is clear: R-134a will face increasing regulatory pressure over the next decade as low-GWP alternatives prove themselves in the field.
R-404A — GWP 3,922
R-404A was the standard for commercial refrigeration and freezing for decades, valued for its performance at low temperatures. But its GWP of 3,922 — nearly 4,000 times the warming impact of CO₂ — makes it a primary target for phase-down.0 models (0.0%) in our database still use R-404A, but the count is declining as manufacturers transition to alternatives.
Several U.S. states (California, New York, Washington, and others) have already banned or restricted R-404A in new commercial refrigeration equipment. Federal regulations under the AIM Act are further limiting its availability. If you are buying new equipment, R-404A is generally not the right choice unless your application specifically requires it and no alternative exists.
What is in the certified fleet today
Across 1,921 commercial refrigerators and freezers with reported refrigerant data, the distribution looks like this:
- R-290: 1,624 models (84.5%)
- R-600a: 244 models (12.7%)
- R-513A: 32 models (1.7%)
- R-450A: 14 models (0.7%)
- R-449A: 6 models (0.3%)
- R-134a: 1 models (0.1%)
The shift toward low-GWP refrigerants is visible in the data — and it will accelerate as regulations tighten and manufacturers bring more R-290 and R-449A models to market.
Other refrigerants you may encounter
- R-449A (GWP 1,397)
- A near drop-in replacement for R-404A with 65% lower GWP. Used as a transitional refrigerant by some manufacturers while R-290 systems scale up.
- R-513A (GWP 631)
- A lower-GWP alternative to R-134a. Non-flammable and compatible with similar system designs.
- R-600a (isobutane, GWP 3)
- Common in residential refrigerators worldwide. Less common in commercial equipment in the U.S. but widely used in Europe.
- R-744 (CO₂, GWP 1)
- Used in large supermarket systems (transcritical CO₂). Rare in self-contained commercial units due to high operating pressures.
What to do with this information
- Check local regulations. Some states restrict R-404A in new installations now.
- Favor low-GWP for new purchases. R-290 models are available in most commercial refrigerator categories and are often more efficient.
- Consider service availability. Ensure local technicians are certified for the refrigerant type you choose.
- Plan for the long term. A refrigerator lasts 10–15 years. Equipment bought today will still be running when high-GWP phase-downs take full effect.
Compare by refrigerant
Every model page on SpecDirectory shows the refrigerant type and GWP rating. Use the commercial refrigerators page to browse and filter by refrigerant type, or compare two models side by side on their comparison page to see how refrigerant choice affects efficiency.